The lowest bid won and then... surprise


You learn plenty of things in Singapore.

2011.

This is a small place… lots of people and not many rivers… and the Government needed another desalination plant.

So it launched a tender.

Logical.

Hyflux offered to supply water for S$0.45 per cubic metre.

Another bidder offered S$0.67.

Guess who won.

Excellent.

A competitive procurement.

An attractive tariff.

A 25-year PPP.

Everyone happy.

Except…

The financial model depended on selling electricity.

If you are in Canada, you’ve probably seen this before with LRTs and metros…

In Spain, I was in another project where there was not much traffic but lots of right of way for solar plants…

Anyway.

So… selling electricity and not just water.

Hyflux planned to build a power plant alongside the desalination facility.

Use some electricity for desalination.

Sell the rest to the grid.

And make enough money to support that beautiful water tariff.

Brilliant.

No comment.

Bids have been won on this strategy.

Unfortunately for the model… electricity prices collapsed.

And the pessimistic case of the financial model started looking Wonderland.

Hyflux collapsed.

And in 2019, Singapore's water agency, PUB, took over the desalination plant.

For S$0.

Sounds like a bargain… although the Government subsequently spent around S$80 million repairing it.

But there is more…

The thing is that Singapore had already delivered its first desalination PPP in 2005.

SingSpring.

Developed by… yes.

Hyflux.

A 20-year concession.

And guess what?

In December 2025, PUB extended that concession for another three years.

Same country.

Same original developer.

Two very different outcomes.

As I always say to my clients on the “client side”.

Perhaps the problem wasn't PPPs per se.

We spend fortunes evaluating tenders.

And then celebrate the lowest price.

But the devil is in the details.

And you need to know and understand very well what you’re buying.

Remember.

Transferring risk to the private sector doesn't make the risk disappear.

It merely identifies who suffers first when the assumptions are wrong.

More about PPPs? Then click below.

​The Room​

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.

Vicente Valencia

Weekly insights on how to perform when it matters | High-stakes decisions. Real situations. No BS. | 👇JOIN +2k readers 👇

Read more from Vicente Valencia

Let's talk about infrastructure pipelines. Not the ones that look beautiful in government presentations. Pre-election and post-election. No. The ones that actually get built. Imagine you're an international contractor. You win one out of every three projects you bid for. Not bad. A respectable success rate. Now imagine the government announces three major projects. Over the next ten years. Three. In a decade. Congratulations. Statistically, you might win one project. In ten years. Now go and...

2002. Again, Singapore. The Government wanted public housing. In the middle of the city. 2.5 hectares. Premium real estate. So they organised an international design competition. More than 200 proposals. 32 countries. And the winner? A small local architectural firm. ARC Studio. Not some enormous multinational consultancy. Not a firm with 17 regional offices. A small Singaporean practice. Imagine that. All is possible in Singapore… Imagine a procurement evaluation committee these days. "Have...

1975. Singapore. The country had already invested S$800 million in Paya Lebar Airport. And needed more capacity. The obvious solution? Expand it. Build a second runway. A no brainer… That's what some foreign experts recommended. The typical sunk cost trap… The country had a different opinion though. The airport was too close to the city. Noise. Pollution. Limited room for expansion. And Singapore intended to grow. A lot. So, they understood one of my mantras when studying infrastructure. Stop...