$800 Million Already Spent. Let's Start Again


1975.

Singapore.

The country had already invested S$800 million in Paya Lebar Airport.

And needed more capacity.

The obvious solution?

Expand it.

Build a second runway.

A no brainer…

That's what some foreign experts recommended.

The typical sunk cost trap…

The country had a different opinion though.

The airport was too close to the city.

Noise.

Pollution.

Limited room for expansion.

And Singapore intended to grow.

A lot.

So, they understood one of my mantras when studying infrastructure.

Stop spending money improving the wrong asset.

Build a new airport.

At Changi.

Cost?

S$1.5 billion.

And the S$800 million already invested?

Written off for its original purpose.

Paya Lebar would become a military airbase.

Now, imagine presenting that proposal to a modern Steering Committee.

And I’m not inventing anything, this is a real recent case I witnessed.

"We've already invested too much."

"Can we optimise the existing asset?"

"We need an independent review."

“Improving ALWAYS better than building new… and it’s MORE SUSTAINABLE”

And my favourite.

"Let's not rush into a decision."

Fortunately, Singapore had people with guts.

And made a decision.

In April 1975, the president of the country was in Washington when the Acting Prime Minister sent him an urgent message.

If Singapore wanted Changi ready by 1981, they needed to decide.

Now.

Lee, the president, replied.

Proceed.

Six years later, Changi Airport opened.

Today, Singapore is building Terminal 5.

Designed to handle another 50 million passengers annually in its first phase.

Not bad for a decision made half a century ago.

Look.

We teach people to defend budgets.

To justify previous decisions.

To protect investments that no longer make sense.

So they keep spending billions to justify the millions they've already spent.

Pure financial Stockholm syndrome.

And let me tell you something.

Good leadership isn't defending yesterday's decision.

It's having the courage to make tomorrow's right one.

Even when it makes yesterday's spreadsheet look stupid.

If you are about to make important decisions in infrastructure, click below.

$49.90

1:1 The First Call

A PPP decision on your desk? Let’s talk.
A letter you need to send. A claim you need to respond to. A project issue... Read more

​

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.

Vicente Valencia

Weekly insights on how to perform when it matters | High-stakes decisions. Real situations. No BS. | 👇JOIN +2k readers 👇

Read more from Vicente Valencia

I’m in Singapore today and this is amazing. The level in its infrastructure is worth studying. However, as a good engineer, I love comparing. Come to me to Greece. More than 2,400 years ago, the ancient Greeks decided to build a tunnel through a mountain on the island of Samos. One kilometre long to bring water from one point to the other. Not much for these days… although they did not use the billion dollars as measurement unit… Now add. A tunnel through solid rock. The engineer was called...

2,500 years ago, the Persian Empire controlled an enormous territory. No internet. No smartphones. No WhatsApp groups that suck your blood, your energy and even money. And of course, no consultants preparing weekly PowerPoint updates. And they understood something important. Information is power. But only if it's accurate. And arrives on time. The Persians developed an extraordinary system of roads, relay stations and mounted couriers. Messengers changed horses. Day and night. It worked like...

There's a fascinating way to save money in infrastructure. Stop building. Apparently, someone in the UK thought this was a brilliant idea. Take HS2. If you think the name of this railway project is spectacular, you should wait to see the cost overruns. The Government needed to control spending. Understandable. So what did they do? They delayed construction work. Reduced annual expenditure. And presumably celebrated the savings. Excellent. No money no deal… Except… if you need a piece of...