|
I love going to local markets. ​ I tried one this weekend. ​ All vendors shouting: “Try this.” “Taste that.” “Best cheese in town.” “Organic honey.” ​ Everyone fighting for your attention. ​ It’s nice. It feels human. You try things. You buy things. You feel good helping local producers. ​ I love that. ​ But price is sometimes an issue. ​ It’s not cheap. And it can’t be cheap. ​ These guys work at very small scale. Their margins need to be enormous just to make a living. ​ I don’t blame them. ​ And honestly, paying a high margin on 50 or 100 dollars doesn’t hurt your pocket too much. You feel generous. You feel supportive. You feel like a good citizen. ​ But now imagine this logic applied to a $50 million or $100 million infrastructure project. ​ That’s exactly what many governments do. ​ They are obsessed with using the local and weak supply chain. In construction contracts, they: Incentivize it Or simply impose it ​ “Use local companies.” “Protect small suppliers.” “Support the domestic market.” ​ It sounds noble. It sounds fair. It sounds political gold. ​ But… It’s like throwing a few pieces of bread to small fish. ​ It does not help them grow. It just keeps them alive. ​ You end up doing two things at the same time: You overspend on infrastructure You keep your supply chain in permanent survival mode ​ No scale. No technology. No learning curve. No real competitiveness. ​ Just dependency. ​ It may be politically palatable. Weak leaders like to be liked. They fear backlash. They avoid bold decisions. ​ But let’s be brutally honest: You’re not strengthening your supply chain. You’re freezing it in weakness. ​ To grow strong, you don’t need bread. ​ You need meat. You need investment. You need exposure to world-class players. You need real competition. You need knowledge transfer. You need scale. ​ Protection creates fragility. Challenge creates strength. ​ I’m involved right now in a case like this. ​ The solution is simple. ​ But it’s not politically correct. ​ It requires saying: “We want the best.” “We want efficiency.” “We want partners who can build and operate world-class infrastructure.” “And we want our local companies to grow by learning, not by being sheltered.” ​ Not as charity. Not as social policy. But as an engine of transformation. ​ More on this, and why most governments get it wrong, below. ​Vicente Valencia Academy ​ ​ PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day. PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below. ​ ​ |
I talk about Personal Growth, Management, Infrastructure and More | 👇JOIN +2k readers 👇
I’m an engineer. By accident. But an engineer nevertheless. I’ve seen landslides during construction, and after construction. Specifications not converting properly between inches and cm. Expansion joints popping up in summer like popcorn. Pavement failing in the first winter after opening. Subcontractors going broke. Or bought by the competition you stole the project from… But still… 80% of serious PPP failures are NOT technical… They are contractual. Risk allocation errors Toxic KPI regimes...
You know I’m no fan of the World Bank. But from time to time, curiosity opens some doors. This is what I found. More than 50% of PPPs are renegotiated… Let that sink in. 50%. And usually in favor of the private sector... 50–60% of PPP contracts in developed countriesand up to 70% in emerging marketsare renegotiated within the first 5–7 years. So the contract you sign is not the contract you live with. What does it mean? Simple… It means the real risk allocationis not the one approved by...
This week I received a message from a subscriber that should make every government, agency, and consulting firm uncomfortable. It came from a man who led one of the most successful Education PPPs in the world. A $165 million program funded by USAID.Implemented across 10 districts in Sindh, Pakistan.State-of-the-art schools.A pioneering Education Management Organization (EMO) model.One of the few genuine unsolicited PPP projects in the country.A full PPP Guide & Toolkit still in use today. He...