Havard experts said buses. Singapore showed them the middle fing...


1980.

Singapore.

Traffic.

Congestion.

A growing population.

And an increasingly urgent need for public transport.

So they did what any sensible government would do.

They hired experts.

In this case… including specialists from Harvard.

Very clever people.

Their recommendation?

Of course… Buses.

More buses.

Why spend S$5 billion on trains, the estimate at the time, when buses are cheaper?

However, the Finance Minister, someone with some vision and understanding of user experience as well as some critical spirit, wasn't convinced the railway was worth the money either.

And you can understand the guy.

Five billion was an enormous investment.

Especially for a relatively young country.

But someone asked a rather interesting question… a question I’m an advocate, by the way.

What if we stopped evaluating the railway as just a transport project and we use it to transform the city?

Unlock land.

Support higher density.

Increase property values.

Attract investment.

And accommodate future growth.

You know… normal things… when you have a wholistic approach.

You are bold.

And have the guts.

Of course, now, the financial equation looks different.

In May 1982, Singapore approved the MRT.

S$5 billion.

Construction started in 1983.

The first trains ran in 1987.

The original 67-kilometre network was completed in 1990.

Two years ahead of schedule.

15% below budget.

Imagine that… Hello Auckland!

A major infrastructure project delivered early.

And below budget.

Someone should organise a study to understand how that happened.

Perhaps an independent review.

Followed workshops.

And some relationship consultants.

Don’t you think?

Anyway.

We spend fortunes comparing delivery options.

Capital costs. Operating costs. Risk matrices. Financial models…

All perfectly necessary.

But we usually forget to ask what the investment actually enables.

And administrations are not able to have a long term and coordinated vision… sustained for years.

We optimise the asset, instead of optimising the outcome.

And then congratulate ourselves for selecting the cheapest option.

Olé. Bravo.

You've saved money building something that may not solve the real problem.

Now, to be fair, Singapore didn't rush blindly into the MRT.

They spent years studying the alternatives.

But eventually… they decided.

And built.

Perhaps that's the real lesson.

Good governance doesn't mean avoiding expensive decisions.

It means understanding what you're really buying.

And having the courage to proceed.

If interested in more cases like this, you know where to click.

​The Room​

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.

Vicente Valencia

Weekly insights on how to perform when it matters | High-stakes decisions. Real situations. No BS. | 👇JOIN +2k readers 👇

Read more from Vicente Valencia

You learn plenty of things in Singapore. 2011. This is a small place… lots of people and not many rivers… and the Government needed another desalination plant. So it launched a tender. Logical. Hyflux offered to supply water for S$0.45 per cubic metre. Another bidder offered S$0.67. Guess who won. Excellent. A competitive procurement. An attractive tariff. A 25-year PPP. Everyone happy. Except… The financial model depended on selling electricity. If you are in Canada, you’ve probably seen...

Let's talk about infrastructure pipelines. Not the ones that look beautiful in government presentations. Pre-election and post-election. No. The ones that actually get built. Imagine you're an international contractor. You win one out of every three projects you bid for. Not bad. A respectable success rate. Now imagine the government announces three major projects. Over the next ten years. Three. In a decade. Congratulations. Statistically, you might win one project. In ten years. Now go and...

2002. Again, Singapore. The Government wanted public housing. In the middle of the city. 2.5 hectares. Premium real estate. So they organised an international design competition. More than 200 proposals. 32 countries. And the winner? A small local architectural firm. ARC Studio. Not some enormous multinational consultancy. Not a firm with 17 regional offices. A small Singaporean practice. Imagine that. All is possible in Singapore… Imagine a procurement evaluation committee these days. "Have...