Kenya may have explained toll-road PPPs better than many rich countries.

I know.

Uncomfortable.

The normal script is different.

Rich countries teach.

Emerging markets learn.

Someone says “capacity building.”

Everyone nods.

Beautiful.

Except sometimes fiscal pressure creates better thinking than comfort.

Kenya’s Rironi–Nakuru–Mau Summit Highway is interesting because the government seems to have asked the ugly question that someone needs to answer:

Who pays?

It’s a beautiful project… you should check the case study.

Anyway.

The easy model for a government was an availability-payment PPP.

Private sector designs, builds, finances, operates and maintains.

Government pays every year.

Users do not see the bill directly.

Politically cleaner.

Very elegant.

Very dangerous if you do not have fiscal space.

No, thanks.

So the project moved toward a user-pay toll PPP.

Users contribute directly.

Government keeps oversight.

If revenues outperform, the upside can be shared or reinvested.

Not perfect.

Traffic forecasts lie.

Truckers complain.

Politics explodes.

Welcome to toll roads.

But the question for governments is always the same:

How do we bring private capital without creating a 30-year headache for Treasury?

And yes, someone will always suggest the elegant cousin:

The shadow toll.

No angry driver.

Government pays the private partner based on traffic.

Very smooth.

Until Treasury realises traffic risk did not disappear.

It just moved from the driver’s wallet to the public budget.

This is the lesson for countries still resisting the pay per use infrastructure.

Availability payment.

Shadow toll.

Real toll.

Hybrid.

Government contribution.

Revenue sharing.

Different tools.

Different risks.

Different future explanations.

Risk does not disappear.

It changes address.

So start with:

“Who really pays?”

Then:

“What risk are they taking?”

Then the question nobody likes:

“Can we defend this answer ten years from now?”

Use this information at your own risk.

To solve your infrastructure projects, you can click below.

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.