They wanted to save money.

Of course.

Because nothing says “excellent public procurement” like taking a complex, mission-critical system and pretending the cheap option is also the clever option.

In 2007, the Queensland Government in Australia needed a new payroll system for Queensland Health.

Not a tiny organisation.

Tens of thousands of employees, multiple awards, complex rosters, allowances, overtime, penalties, shifts…

The kind of payroll system that makes normal payroll systems cry in the shower.

The budget was around A$100 million.

Other bidders reportedly said:

“This is not enough.”

Their bids were around A$150–200 million.

IBM came in lower.

Lovely.

Champagne.

Value for money.

Procurement success.

Except… not really.

The system went live in 2010.

And then thousands of health workers were underpaid, overpaid, or not paid properly.

Imagine being a nurse, finishing a brutal shift, going home exhausted, checking your bank account…

And discovering that the “innovative solution” has decided you can live on vibes.

The final cost after the initial mess?

Not A$100 million.

Not A$150 million.

Not even A$200 million.

The Commission of Inquiry estimated the mess would cost around A$1.2 billion over the following years.

That is not a cost overrun.

That is procurement setting itself on fire, then invoicing the taxpayer for the petrol.

The official inquiry later said IBM should not have been appointed.

But the real lesson is bigger.

Sometimes the expensive bid is not expensive.

It is just honest.

And sometimes the cheap bid is not cheap.

It is just the first invoice.

The rest comes later.

In claims.

In delays.

In fixes.

In reputation damage.

In investigations.

In political embarrassment.

In people losing trust.

So next time someone celebrates because they saved a few little dollars in an RFP…

Ask the uncomfortable question:

Did we save money?

Or did we just buy the cheapest entrance ticket to hell?

You need to be in the room to ask and respond those questions.

​The Room​

PD 1: If you liked this email, don't keep it in secret and forward it to a friend. They will thank you enormously one day.

PD 2: If somebody has sent you this email and you want to receive emails like this yourself, visit vicentevalencia.com

PD 3: If you want unsubscribe, click the link below.